Be Prepared
A.V. Walters
When I was just a kid, ten or eleven, “they” started a Girl Guide troop in my village. I was elated. The Boy Scouts—the male version of our Canadian youth organization—did all kinds of cool stuff. They hiked. They went camping. They learned sailing and essential survival skills. I wanted in.
But, Girl Guides was a major disappointment. We met regularly, paid our dues and stood around in formation. There was a lot of discussion about earning badges—and we all eagerly researched the requirements in our Guidebooks. There were no nature hikes, no tips on identifying wildlife, no talks on campfire safety (and, needless to say, no campfires.) Oddly enough, there were tips for the application of cosmetics. And, they emphasized the gentle arts of knitting, crochet, sewing, and swapping patterns. If I’d wanted that, I could’ve simply signed up for Home Ec, at school.
Just once, we had a promising project. We made camp stoves out of coffee cans, which were to be used with beeswax candles as fuel. Of course, when we’d finished with the tinsnips and wax, some of us decided to light the damn things. Our Girl Guide leader had a total fit. You’d have thought we were trying to burn down the building! “Who brought those matches?!!!”
I was a problem child. So, naturally, I complained. The organizers, a trio of women from our village, told me to be patient, that they were just getting started. But, I was bored. To amuse myself, I did handstands against the walls. My concerns (and restlessness) stirred up the other girls, inspiring them to look beyond handicrafts and sock-puppets in their expectations. We started practicing gymnastic moves when the meetings were slow or disorganized. Our leaders didn’t approve of gymnastics. (Admittedly, it’s difficult to keep your Girl Guide uniform neat and tidy while practicing gymnastics.) Consequently, I earned demerits, and was soon regarded as a disciplinary problem.
Meanwhile, the Boy Scouts continued their outings to neat locations, like the local Provincial Parks, and did nature hikes. Could we do that? The response was a “hike,” but not in a park. It was through our village, and down the local highway—marching. Marching In formation. We did about six miles. The other girls groaned. This wasn’t anyone’s idea of fun. Essentially, the entire troop was being punished because of my entreaties. I considered quitting.
Before giving up, I started asking the girls from next town over what they did in their Girl Guide meetings. Needless to say, their troop was far more active and interesting than ours. And, their dues were only a dime a week, while ours were a quarter. Of course, I pressed further, asking other girls, even farther afield what they paid in dues. Always, the answer was the same—a dime.
Finally, I brought it up at one of our meetings, pointing out that other troops paid a lot less and got more out of Girl Guides. Our leaders seemed a bit unnerved at my public questioning. They weakly explained that the excess was used to purchase their uniforms and to cover “incidental” costs. They were volunteers, after all! I retorted that we had to pay for our own uniforms—and we were just kids. I had done the math, and pointed out that uniforms for the three leaders could have been fully paid in three to six months—but that the imposed surcharge had gone on for nearly a year. (Obviously a young girl, like myself, had no appreciation of the cost of a used coffee can.) I knew it wasn’t like we were talking big money, but it was the principle of the thing.
At the end of the meeting, I was unceremoniously kicked out of Girl Guides. Gone. I should have, but I sure didn’t see that coming. I guess I wasn’t cut out to be a Girl Guide. Our motto was, after all, “Be Prepared.”
Needless to say, it was no real loss; it wasn’t much fun, anyway.
A couple of years ago, I joined Facebook. As an indie author, I was told that social media was an important part of our “branding.” So, I put my blog feed through Facebook and accumulated a wide variety of “friends.” Though I enjoyed it, my Facebook page never did much of anything from a marketing perspective.
In 2015 and 2016 my Facebook activities widened to include political expressions. I wrote on issues of food and agricultural policies, climate change and the upcoming elections. I joined groups and made even more “friends.” My topics of discussion included resistance politics, protests and, of course, the elections.
Occasionally, I was trolled, challenged on my positions. Some politicians and political organizations were using paid trolls in their programs of disinformation. In my posts, I was always civil and thorough. If you challenged me, you’d best have your facts straight, because I was ready with mine. I’d research the trolls and, in pretty short order, could tell who was a legitimate person, and who was there just to make trouble. Real people had real friends, and they had longtime Facebook accounts, populated by photos and comments and, well, lives. I attracted the trouble-makers.
One day, recently, I tried to log-in to my Facebook account and was greeted with this:
“HELP US IDENTIFY YOU-
We’re working hard to make sure everyone
on Facebook can be their authentic selves.
We don’t allow accounts that:
- Pretend to be someone else
- Don’t represent a real person
From time to time, we check to make sure
it’s really you with a few short questions
before you log into Facebook. It won’t take long
and it helps keep Facebook safe for everyone.”
What? I’ve been booted off Facebook?!
The successive security screens informed me that, in order to regain access to Facebook, I’d have to upload a copy of a government-issued, photo ID. Some troll (or trolls) had fingered me! Of course I’m a real person. My posts were always thoughtful, cogent and informative. While I’m shocked that the exotic Facebook Algorithms couldn’t recognize my obvious humanity, I’m equally appalled that it is so easy to silence the voice of someone with whom you might simply disagree. I have a “liberal’s” extreme distaste for Big Brother tactics and I’ll be damned if I’ll provide ID in exchange for access to cat videos, photos of restaurant food and trolls. Make the damned trolls show their ID. For no clearly articulated reason, I’ve been kicked off Facebook.
They talk about Facebook withdrawal. Admittedly, I spent too much time on the site. It’s a major mind-suck. And, like any junkie, I’d talked about cutting back, or quitting, altogether. (“I can quit anytime I want. I’ve done it a million times.”) Hell, a recent study even suggested that low doses of LSD can eliminate Facebook Addiction! But I didn’t see this coming, either. I’m out—cold turkey. I’ve completely disappeared from Facebook. It’s as though I’d never existed. Gone. And, there is no way to communicate with the minions of Facebook to question why I vanished, or to explore other options.
There’s a recurring theme, here. I guess that in my own way, I’m a born troublemaker.
So, I’m recovering my personal time and enjoying it. In any event, the lesson is clear: Be Prepared.
It’s OK baby sister, I still love you, and I got kicked of of Guides too, but, for the life of me I have no idea why. I also got kicked of of ballet when I was 5, I talked too much. Go figure, must run in the family.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have few memories of you in Guides. Maybe you were kicked out even before me. I do remember Vaughn, because she was the one who told Mom I was ejected!
LikeLike
Scan the drivers license fer pete’s sake. Your local meijer store has more juice on you than that! Unless you just want to give up. Didn’t figure you for a quitter AV.
LikeLike
Not a quitter, but I am enjoying the quiet. I had committed to a certain level of activity for the various campaigns, and it was taking hours out of my regular day. In the post-Facebook calm I’ve actually almost finished another banjo rehabilitation and I’m learning to play the banjolin. I dunno, how many addicts say they can handle just a little bit….
LikeLike
I’m glad you led with the Girl Guides story. I was chuckling at your precociousness–enjoying your nerve. If you’d led with FB, I might have been outraged instead.
But, on the other hand, many of the social media platforms seem to be becoming more about right-think and less about transparency. Losing FB may not be a big loss in the fullness of time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, I was a problem child. And as my husband notes, people don’t change, they just become more of themselves. The first week was tough, but I’m not missing Facebook now.
LikeLike
You can get a new site on fb w/a different email address. If you want one. But maybe better off without it.
LikeLike
Yes, I know. Or I could just upload the damned ID. But my obligations have concluded and I am enjoying the quiet that comes with ‘just a blog.’ I’m getting a lot done.
LikeLike
What???
I didn’t know Facebook could do that. Require you to upload a gov’t issued ID?? That sounds like a possible attempted identity theft to me. Ridiculous. I could see booting someone for abusive behavior, but as you say, Facebook mines our personal data in such a sophisticated and thorough way that I find it hard to believe they can’t identify an obviously real person.
I certainly know what you mean about the addictive power of that site. I joined Facebook years ago so I could spy on my kids. After a while I was addicted. I found myself checking it multiple times a day. Many, probably most, of my “friends” were people I barely knew. I’ve often resolved to quit, but while my use is way down I’m still on there. All in all I think the good of social media outweighs the bad, but maybe it wouldn’t be such a bad thing if I got kicked off the island, too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Spying on your kids, eh? It seems you were on to the real use of Facebook long before the rest of us. It seems that Facebook spies on all of us, to sell our data and preferences to the highest bidder. They can tell that I looked at a wool shirt on LLBean, or banjo parts on EBay, but they cannot tell if I’m a real person? Give me a break.
LikeLike
Once a rebel, always a rebel. Amelia
LikeLiked by 1 person
What can I say, I must have a dozen similar stories. My mother just rolls her eyes.
LikeLike
I went to the 10 cent troop…it was way more fun! We went on real hikes in the woods!👍
LikeLike
Ah, but you had Tecumseh connections.
LikeLike